Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

dosc: move glossary and add some more details about vulnerabilities and advisories #1106

Open
wants to merge 3 commits into
base: main
Choose a base branch
from
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
1 change: 1 addition & 0 deletions docs/book/antora.yml
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -5,3 +5,4 @@ start_page: ROOT:index.adoc
nav:
- modules/ROOT/nav.adoc
- modules/admin/nav.adoc
- modules/concepts/nav.adoc
2 changes: 2 additions & 0 deletions docs/book/modules/admin/examples/trustify/database.tf
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -122,4 +122,6 @@ resource "aws_db_instance" "trustify" {
skip_final_snapshot = true

availability_zone = var.availability-zone

performance_insights_enabled = true
}
2 changes: 2 additions & 0 deletions docs/book/modules/concepts/nav.adoc
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
* xref:concepts:index.adoc[Concepts]
** xref:concepts:a_v.adoc[Advisories & vulnerabilities]
11 changes: 11 additions & 0 deletions docs/book/modules/concepts/pages/a_v.adoc
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
= Advisories & vulnerabilities

Trustify learns about xref:index.adoc#vulnerability[vulnerabilities] by ingesting advisories. During the ingestion
process, Trustify extracts and aggregates vulnerability information, grouped by their vulnerability identifier.

Advisories can contain multiple vulnerabilities and can scope the application of statements the advisories make to
certain packages. This means that Trustify has an aggregated set of information for a vulnerability, where information
from the Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) project supersedes information from more specific advisories.

Trustify also has "vulnerabilities belonging to an advisory", which contain specific vulnerability information,
provided by that advisory.
93 changes: 93 additions & 0 deletions docs/book/modules/concepts/pages/index.adoc
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,93 @@
= Concepts

The following sections explain a few concepts of Trustify.

[#vulnerability]
== Vulnerability

A vulnerability is primarily a *name* for ensuring all advisories are discussing the same thing.
Generally, most vulnerabilities come from the CVE Project, with the format of `CVE-2024-1234`.

Within the database, Trustify adds the vulnerability when discovering an advisory mentioning it.

A *CVE Record* from National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)/National Vulnerabilities Database (NVD) is a
low-value advisory that is generally the first discovered advisory that mentions a vulnerability.

== Advisory

An advisory is an opinion about a vulnerability.

These opinions include the context to which the opinions apply.
These opinions include evaluation of the severity and scoring of a vulnerability within that context, such as
Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) scores.

As mentioned above, a *CVE Record* from the CVE Project is a low-value advisory that mentions the vulnerability and provides a base opinion about it.
It might include CVSS scores, within the context of the abstract origin containing the vulnerability.
This might be simply in reference to the vulnerability *as it exists in source-code form*.

Other, more-involved stakeholders, such as, product vendors, upstream project owners, might issue *additional*
advisories.
These opinions might be in reference to *concrete*, shipped products, contextualized to how the vulnerable code is *actually used*.

== SBOM

An SBOM is a source-of-someone's-truth about "what's inside it?", so
everything in our DB is ultimately sourced from some
source-of-truth. We cannot really say definitively "product X is
composed of A1, A2 + A3". Instead, we can have multiple simultaneous
statements -- SBOM's -- from multiple people saying "product X is
claimed by Bob to be A1 + A2" and "product X is claimed by Jim to be
A1 + A97". So an SBOM is the entity to track the origin of the
supposed "evidence" of assertional statements about products... about
packages... about vulnerabilities...

== Package

A package is an atomic artifact or component.
Packages can be addressed using pURLs.
A package can be described by an SBOM describing how it is created and its contents.
A package can certainly contain other packages. For example, shading one Java jar into another.
A package can also be the sole member of a product. For example `UBI-8.0.13-x86.oci` can be the singular package within the "UBI 8.0.13-x86" product.
A package is one step more abstract than an *artifact*.

=== pURL

Package URLs (pURLs) are possibly ambiguous names applied to packages.
A simple pURL such as `pkg:maven/org.apache/[email protected]` can or cannot refer to a unique artifact.
With additional qualifiers, it is possible to produce a URI that asserts uniqueness, such as `pkg:maven/org.apache/[email protected]?repository_url=repo.jboss.com`.
Without additional qualifiers, the implicit aspects, such as `repository_url`, must be taken into account.
For instance, an unqualified `pkg:maven` pURL *implies* "the jar from Maven Central, and none other".

== Product

A product is a *named collection of 1 or more packages* for a concrete shippable thing.

Products can be addressed using Common Platform Enumerations (CPE) or some other future identification method.
A product can be described by an SBOM describing its components, which might be other products or packages, or their SBOMs.

NOTE: Given Red Hat Product Security definitions, grouping of products might need to occur within some sense of product
versions, or product streams.

`Red Hat Enterprise Linux 8` might be a *product stream*.
`Red Hat Enterprise Linux 8.2.03 PowerPC` might be a concrete *product* distinct from `Red Hat Enterprise Linux 8.2.03 AArch64`.

=== CPE

A CPE is a "Common Product Enumeration" from the NIST organization.
CPEs are self-assigned but registered occasionally with NIST.
CPEs describe the vendor, the product, the version, target architecture, etc.
CPEs can also be non-fully specified, to use as pattern-matching.
For instance, "All versions of Red Hat Enterprise Linux 8.2.013, regardless of platform", or if more fully-specified,
could imply "All versions of Red Hat Enterprise Linux 8.x on AArch64".

NOTE: CPEs are somewhat contentious, and used enough for us to not ignore, but not used enough to be a pivotal definition of "product" for any users of Trustify.

== Artifact

For a given *package*, there can be zero or more instances of that package.
Given `log4j-1.2.3.jar`, seventeen different people could compile the same source with the same arguments, and still end
up with 17 distinct Java jars, due to non-reproducible builds.
Each is an artifact of the *same* package.
Each might, and most likely will, have its own SHA-256 related to it.

Consider an *artifact* to be a concrete *instance* of a package.
89 changes: 1 addition & 88 deletions docs/glossary.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,88 +1 @@
# Glossary of Understanding

## Entities

### Vulnerability

A vulnerability is mostly, primarily a *name* that is used to ensure all advisories are discussing the same thing.
Generally, to this point, most vulnerabilities come from the CVE Project, with the format of `CVE-2024-1234`.

Within the database, generally a vulnerability is added as a side effect of an advisory mentioning it.

A *CVE Record* from NIST/NVD is a low-value advisory that is generally the first discovered advisory that mentions a vulnerability.

### Advisory

An advisory is an opinion about a vulnerability.

These opinions include the context to which the opinions apply.
These opinions include evaluation of the severity and scoring of a vulnerability within that context, such as CVSS scores.

As mentioned above, a *CVE Record* from the CVE Project is a low-value advisory that mentions the vulnerability and provide a base opinion about it.
It may include CVSS scores, within the context of the abstract origin containing the vulnerability.
This may be simply in reference to the vulnerability *as it exists in source-code form*.

Other, more-involved stakeholders (product vendors, upstream project owners) may issue *additional* advisories.
These opinions may be in reference to *concrete* shipped products, contextualized to how the vulnerable code is *actually used*.

### SBOM

An SBOM is a source-of-someone's-truth about "what's inside it?", so
everything in our DB is ultimately sourced from some
source-of-truth. We can't really say definitively "product X is
composed of A1, A2 + A3". Instead, we can have multiple simultaneous
statements -- SBOM's -- from multiple people saying "product X is
claimed by Bob to be A1 + A2" and "product X is claimed by Jim to be
A1 + A97". So an SBOM is the entity to track the origin of the
supposed "evidence" of assertional statements about products... about
packages... about vulnerabilities...

### Package

A package is an atomic artifact or component.
Packages may be addressed using pURLs.
A package may be described by an SBOM describing how it is created and its contents.
A package may certainly contain other packages (e.g. shading one Java jar into another).
A package may also be the sole member of a Product (`UBI-8.0.13-x86.oci` may be the singular package within the "UBI 8.0.13-x86" product).
A package is one step more abstract than an *artifact*.

#### pURL

Package URLs (pURLs) are possibly ambiguous names applied to packages.
A simple pURL such as `pkg:maven/org.apache/[email protected]` may or may not refer to a unique artifact.
With additional qualifiers, it is possible to produce a URI that asserts uniqueness, such as `pkg:maven/org.apache/[email protected]?repository_url=repo.jboss.com`.
Without additional qualifiers, the implicit aspects (such as `repository_url`) must be taken into account.
For instance, an unqualified `pkg:maven` pURL *implies* "the jar from Maven Central, and none other".

### Product

A product is a *named collection of 1 or more packages* for a concrete shippable thing.

Products may be addressed using CPEs or some other future identification method.
A product may be described by an SBOM describing its components, which may be other products or packages, or their SBOMs.

> [!NOTE]
> Given ProdSec definitions, grouping of Products may need to occur within some sense of Product Versions, or Product Streams.

`RHEL8` may be a *product stream*.
`RHEL 8.2.03 PowerPC` may be a concrete *product* distinct from `RHEL 8.2.03 AArch64`.

#### CPE

A CPE is a "Common Product Enumeration" from the NIST organization.
CPEs are self-assigned, but registered occasionally with NIST.
CPEs describe the vendor, the product, the version, target architecture, etc.
CPEs may also be non-fully specified, to use as pattern-matching.
For instance, "All versions of RHEL 8.2.013, regardless of platform", or if more fully-specified, could imply "All versions of RHEL 8.x on AArch64".

> [!NOTE]
> CPEs are somewhat contentious, and used enough for us to not ignore, but not used enough to be a pivotal definition of "product" for any users of Trustify.

### Artifact

For a given *package*, there may be zero or more instances of that package.
Given `log4j-1.2.3.jar`, seventeen different people could compile the same source with the same arguments, and still end up with 17 distinct Java jars (due to non-reproducible builds).
Each is an artifact of the *same* package.
Each may (will probably) have its own SHA-256 related to it.

Consider an *artifact* to be a concrete *instance* of a package.
See [book/modules/concepts/pages/index.adoc](book/modules/concepts/pages/index.adoc).
Loading