-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
feat(Image&Location): swiper, auto update location #13
Conversation
"tailwind-merge": "^1.14.0", | ||
"tailwindcss-animate": "^1.0.7", | ||
"zod": "^3.22.4" | ||
}, | ||
"devDependencies": { | ||
"@types/node": "^20.8.0", | ||
"@types/react": "^18.2.15", | ||
"@types/react": "^18.2.74", | ||
"@types/react-dom": "^18.2.7", | ||
"@types/react-slick": "^0.23.13", | ||
"@typescript-eslint/eslint-plugin": "^6.0.0", |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
This patch appears to be an update to a project's package.json
file, which manages project dependencies. Here are some thoughts on the changes:
-
Added Dependencies:
@types/swiper
: This addition is fine if you're planning to use Swiper in your project and need TypeScript type definitions for it.axios
: A prominent HTTP client for browsers and Node.js. Since it's being added, make sure that you are indeed going to use it or replace an existing solution with it to avoid unnecessary bloat.gsap
: An animation library. It should be added only if there is a necessity for complex animations that cannot be easily accomplished with CSS animations.styled-components
: A library used to style React components using tagged template literals. Ensure that this addition aligns with the project's architecture and there is no overlap with other styling solutions like TailwindCSS that might lead to confusion or conflicts.swiper
: Necessary for if you're adding carousels and want to use the Swiper library.
-
Version Updates:
- The versions of several packages have been updated. This is typically good, assuming that the updates do not introduce breaking changes and the rest of the codebase is compatible with these new versions.
- Notable major version changes could involve backward-incompatible changes; you'll want to consult the changelog for each of these updates to ensure that they do not affect your implementation.
-
Potential Risks/Concerns:
- Mixing Styling Solutions: As mentioned, adding
styled-components
when you already have TailwindCSS could cause some confusion about how styling is handled throughout the project. You'd want to make sure there's consensus from the team before choosing multiple styling approaches. - Unused Dependencies: Adding dependencies that are not used within the project can contribute to longer install times, larger bundle sizes, and potential maintenance overhead. Always verify the need before including a new package.
- Upgrading Types for React (
@types/react
): This change indicates an increment in the patch version. Although minor, it’s always best practice to ensure no typing issues were introduced that can affect the build process or develop time experience.
- Mixing Styling Solutions: As mentioned, adding
-
General Suggestions:
- Verify breaking changes: For every upgraded package, check that there are no breaking changes affecting your project. Have tests or perform manual testing as needed.
- Consider deduplicating: If there are similar libraries that serve the same purpose (like axios and another HTTP library), consider keeping just one to reduce duplication.
- Where is
react-query-devtools
? It was in the original list but not in the modified one, which might be intended, or it might have been removed by mistake. - Ensure compatibility: If
swiper
andstyled-components
are new to the project, ensure that their versions are compatible with other dependencies and the current codebase.
To wrap it up, reviewing the patch doesn't turn up immediate red flags, but it's important to audit these additions and version bumps in the context of the whole project to ensure compatibility and necessity.
width: 350px !important; | ||
height: 200px !important; /* 在小屏幕上减小高度 */ | ||
} | ||
} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
This code patch appears to be CSS intended for styling elements related to a Swiper slider, a popular library used for creating slideshows and carousels on websites. Here's the review covering potential issues and opportunities for improvement:
General Observations:
-
Commented-out Code: The first block of styles is commented out. If this code is unnecessary, it's usually best to remove it to reduce clutter.
-
Use of
!important
: The usage of!important
is generally discouraged unless absolutely necessary because it makes debugging and maintaining the code harder by breaking the natural cascading in your style sheets. -
Consistency in Language Comments: Comments are written in Chinese which is perfectly fine if the development team uses Chinese. However, if the team is international, it might be better to stick to English to maintain consistency.
-
Responsive Design Consideration: The media query adjusts the size of
.mySwiper
based on the screen width, which is good for responsive design. However, depending on the actual layout requirements, more breakpoints or different strategies (like using percentages or vw/vh units) might be needed for better responsiveness across various devices.
Specific Suggestions for Improvement:
-
Removing
!important
if possible: Refractor the specificity of your selectors or the order of the CSS to avoid using!important
. This will make it easier to understand and overwrite styles when needed without resorting to more!important
tags. -
Accessibility Considerations: Ensure that text within
.swiper-slide
elements has sufficient contrast with its background (#fff
) for readability. Also, consider including descriptivealt
texts for images for screen readers. -
Performance: Direct modification of elements' widths and heights can lead to layout shifts, affecting user experience. It’s good practice to optimize images for the web to ensure they load faster without sacrificing quality, especially since
object-fit: cover
may result in downloading larger images than necessary. -
Viewport Units for Responsiveness: Instead of switching to fixed sizes at different breakpoints, consider using viewport units (
vw
,vh
,vmin
,vmax
) for the dimensions of.mySwiper
to make it more fluid and adaptable to various screen sizes without the need for multiple breakpoints. -
Verifying
object-fit
Support: Whileobject-fit
is widely supported in modern browsers, verify its compatibility if your audience includes users on older browsers whereobject-fit
may not work as expected.
Conclusion:
Overall, this CSS snippet targets specific styling for a Swiper component. While it has a good base, focusing on avoiding !important
when possible, improving responsiveness with more fluid units, ensuring accessibility, and maintaining clean, commented-out-free code could further refine the approach.
|
||
fetchLocation(); | ||
}, [form]); | ||
|
||
// Query | ||
const { mutateAsync: createPost, isLoading: isLoadingCreate } = | ||
useCreatePost(); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
This code snippet has some positive aspects as well as areas for improvement from both a functionality and best practices perspective. Below, I highlight several points of interest:
-
Use of Hooks and React Patterns:
- Positive: The use of
useEffect
to fetch data on component mount is a common and recommended React pattern. Using async/await within this hook for data fetching is also appropriate. - Improvement: Ensure the cleanup of effects if you expect the component to unmount before the request completes or if there are other side-effects. This isn't directly applicable here as the effect does not return a value, but it's something to be mindful of.
- Positive: The use of
-
Security Concern:
- Risk: Embedding sensitive tokens like
"467f453bf210c1"
directly in your front-end code exposes them to the public, leading to potential misuse. It's better to keep such keys on the server side and create an endpoint in your backend that interacts with theipinfo.io
API.
- Risk: Embedding sensitive tokens like
-
Error Handling:
- Positive: The try/catch block around the axios call is good for catching any errors that might occur during the API call.
- Improvement: While logging errors to the console is a start, consider how these errors should be communicated to the user (if at all). Also, ensure that error handling is consistent across your application.
-
Data Handling and Validation:
- Positive: Setting the fetched location into a form field and triggering validation (
{ shouldValidate: true }
) is good practice to keep the form state consistent and validated. - Suggestion: You could further improve this by handling scenarios where the location cannot be fetched or set correctly, ensuring that your app’s UX is smooth even in the event of API failure or errors.
- Positive: Setting the fetched location into a form field and triggering validation (
-
Performance Consideration:
- Note: Ensure that dependencies of the
useEffect
hook are precisely what should trigger a re-fetch. Includingform
object as a dependency could potentially cause unnecessary re-renders or fetches if theform
object changes in ways that don't impact the need to fetch the location. Given the current implementation, consider if there are more specific properties ofform
that would be more appropriate dependencies.
- Note: Ensure that dependencies of the
-
Dependency Management:
- Positive: Adding new imports as needed (
axios
,React
modules) is good for extending functionality. - Suggestion: Regularly check for updates to your dependencies (
axios
,react-hook-form
, etc.) to take advantage of performance improvements, new features, and security patches.
- Positive: Adding new imports as needed (
-
Coding Style and Comments:
- Improvement: The comment in Chinese might be clear for those who understand it, but generally, comments in widely understood languages (typically English) make your code more accessible to a global developer community.
- Suggestion: Add comments explaining why the fetch is necessary. While the code's purpose might seem obvious now, future developers (or you in the future) will appreciate context around why decisions were made.
-
Hardcoded API URL and Token:
- We already covered the token, but even the base URL "https://ipinfo.io/json" being hardcoded could limit flexibility. For larger applications, consider maintaining your URLs and other constants in a separate configuration file or environment variables which can vary between development, staging, and production environments.
In summary, while this patch introduces useful functionality and follows several best practices, paying attention to security, error handling, maintainability, and performance can lead to a more robust and secure application.
className="post-card_img" | ||
/> | ||
</Link> | ||
)} | ||
|
||
<PostStats post={post} userId={user.id} /> | ||
</div> |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Your code patch introduces a Swiper component to display images in a carousel if there are multiple images associated with a post. Here's a brief review covering potential risks and suggestions for improvement:
General Observations
-
Modular Imports: It's good that specific Swiper components and styles are imported modularly. This can help reduce the bundle size compared to importing the entire Swiper package.
-
CSS Import Inside JS: Importing CSS directly in a JavaScript or TypeScript file (
import "../StorySwiper/StorySwiper.css";
) is acceptable in modern front-end stacks but ensure your build tool (e.g., Webpack, Vite) is configured to handle these imports correctly. -
Comments in English: The comment
// 自动调整高度
is in Chinese, which may not be understandable by all team members. It's generally best to keep code comments in English unless the development team shares a common language.
Potential Issues & Suggestions
-
EffectCube
Module Unused: You've importedEffectCube
but didn't include it in themodules
array of theSwiper
component. If you want the cube effect, it should be added:modules={[Autoplay, Navigation, Scrollbar, EffectCube]}
. -
Commented Out Pagination Style: The import
// import "swiper/css/pagination";
is commented out. If pagination is not needed, consider removing this line entirely for clarity. If you plan to use pagination later, clarify this intention with a comment or add it to your implementation now. -
Implicit Return in
.map()
: Yourmap
function returns JSX implicitly. While not an issue per se, explicit returns can sometimes make the code more readable, especially when debugging or adding new features. This is subjective and can vary based on team preference. -
Error Handling for Image URL: The fallback for
imageUrl
is handled well with a default image. Consider also handling the case where the image fails to load after the initial attempt. A common approach is to listen for theonError
event on the<img>
tag and replace thesrc
with the fallback URL if the original URL fails. -
Key Prop in Map: Using
index
as a key in.map()
is generally okay for static lists, but if the list could change, consider using a more stable identifier related to the data (such as an image ID or hash) to prevent unnecessary re-renders or errors in component state. -
Accessibility (A11y): Ensure that the carousel is accessible. This includes proper ARIA roles and ensuring that controls (if added) are keyboard navigable. Also, consider providing descriptive
alt
texts for images rather than just 'post image {index}'. -
Link Closure Location: Ensure the
</Link>
tag closure (removed at the start of the code snippet and re-added later) aligns correctly with its opening tag to avoid breaking navigation or layout. -
Checking Array Length: You correctly check
post.imageS && post.imageS.length > 0
. However, if you're certain thatpost.imageS
is always an array (even an empty one), you could simplify this topost.imageS.length > 0
.
Improving the code based on these suggestions will enhance maintainability, readability, and functionality.
No description provided.