APP6 Symbols not working as of Runtime 10.2.2

[csmoore]

UPDATE (CSM): I have tested on 100.2 and latest stylx and added a strikethrough for the symbols now drawing see comment below with images - a more comprehensive list of symbol issues with the stylx is in #291

These symbols do not draw:

SHGPUUACRW (Empty Symbol - update as of 10.2.5 the JSON/Content column is also empty for this)
S-UPNA---------
S-UPNBR--------
S-UPNBW--------
S-UPNM---------

These still need a SIDC:

Task - Screen Left F
Task - Screen Left H
Task - Screen Left N
Task - Screen Left U
Task - Screen Right F
Task - Screen Right H
Task - Screen Right N
Task - Screen Right U
Task - Guard Left F
Task - Guard Left H
Task - Guard Left N
Task - Guard Left U
Task - Guard Right F
Task - Guard Right H
Task - Guard Right N
Task - Guard Right U
Task - Cover Left F
Task - Cover Left H
Task - Cover Left N
Task - Cover Left U
Task - Cover Right F
Task - Cover Right H
Task - Cover Right N
Task - Cover Right U
Search Area/Reconnaissance Left F
Search Area/Reconnaissance Left H
Search Area/Reconnaissance Left N
Search Area/Reconnaissance Left U
Search Area/Reconnaissance Right F
Search Area/Reconnaissance Right H
Search Area/Reconnaissance Right N
Search Area/Reconnaissance Right U
Principal Direction OF Fire 1 F
Principal Direction Of Fire 1 H
Principal Direction OF Fire 1 N
Principal Direction OF Fire 1 U
Principal Direction Of Fire 2 F
Principal Direction Of Fire 2 H
Principal Direction Of Fire 2 N
Principal Direction Of Fire 2 U
Antitank Ditch Under Construction
Minefields Dynamic Depiction

[conklinbd]

@csmoore Will these issues need to be fixed in the July release for runtime or should they be added to the 10.2.2. milestone?

[csmoore]

They won't draw without an ID so I guess they should be added to the next milestone/release.

The missing IDs are a data issue - the not drawing ones need further investigation to see where the problems is.

[topowright-zz]

This needs to be tested by the Product Engineers on RunTime 100.2.

We also need to make sure that we have an ongoing way to review Runtime issues.

[topowright-zz]

@csmoore do we have a better understanding of this for our current solution? Also, could you provide an estimate?

[csmoore]

@topowright - I thought this was going to be tested by PEs on the current supported versions of the products.

I did have an action to provide a version of the runtime test app that anyone could run. This application is posted at: https://esri.box.com/s/dt7ejubj12h566mabxotvk1l0fwh4og9 - let me know if that is sufficient.

[topowright-zz]

We are not going to currently work on this because of an open issue in Devtopia, which will then fix the stylx file.

[topowright-zz]

We need to understand how this relates to this issue:
#276
The end result is we need a list of symbols that we do not draw and the steps documented on how we can find those symbols.

[BobBooth]

Getting back up to speed. Updating stylx in my fork of the repo.

[BobBooth]

Ran the comprehensive APP6B bat file. Out of 1,186 items, 11 drew with yellow quatrefoil and one other error (waves going beyond bounding box for SFGPUUMSEJ--) were found.

| SIDC | Display Issue | Should be |
|SFUPNM---------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|SFUPNBW--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|SFUPNBR--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|SFUPNA---------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GHOPPCU--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GHCPMOLAT------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GHCPMOLAE------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GFOPPHG--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GFCPMOOTF------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GFCPBWA--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GFCPBSW--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|SFGPUUMSEJ-----.png | waves go beyond bounding box| | |
|SFUPNBW--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|SFUPNBR--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|SFUPNA---------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GHOPPCU--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GHCPMOLAT------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GHCPMOLAE------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GFOPPHG--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GFCPMOOTF------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GFCPBWA--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|GFCPBSW--------.png | yellow quatrefoil| |
|SFGPUUMSEJ-----.png | waves go beyond bounding box| |

[BobBooth]

@csmoore - in the description of this issue there are several search area items (FHNU for Left and Right)
I'm seeing one output search area item that matches the SIDC pattern in the runtime output:

Can you clarify what the issue is with this?

[csmoore]

@BobBooth - sorry if my comments above were confusing - I was saying these were drawing (each item has a "Not Drawing" "Drawing" description).

[ACueva]

Verified. Ran the following bat file to produce Runtime 100.2 APP6B Military Symbology. https://github.com/Esri/military-features-data/blob/dev/military-symbology-styles/test-data/app6b/ExportScripts/ComprehensiveTestDataBasedOnCMooreFixes.bat

Stylx used: https://github.com/Esri/military-features-data/blob/dev/military-symbology-styles/app6b/app6b.stylx
This is the same Stylx that was used for our April 2018 release.

All requested symbols draw.

[topowright-zz]

We tested this on 100.2 and was verified on 100.2. Changing the title to reflect the work that was done by the team.

[lfunkhouser]

@topowright I changed the title back to the original title. This issue was logged in 2014 and it would not be accurate to say it was a bug at Runtime 100.2. There were several comments with respect to previous versions of Runtime (i.e. Runtime 10.2.2, 10.2.5, etc). This issue was logged for symbols not drawing at Runtime 10.2.2. The symbols have been fixed and tested at Runtime 100.2, which you have indicated in the version label addressed, V - Runtime 100.2. What is the status of the Search Area Reconnaissance Left and Right - they still appear to be issues since they are not crossed out in the original issue description?

[lfunkhouser]

Has the Runtime and Pro teams been given the updated APP-6(B) stylx?

[lfunkhouser]

@topowright @ACueva @BobBooth @csmoore Mentioning all who worked on this issue...
Please update on the status of the Search Area Reconnaissance Left and Right symbols. Also when was the stylx delivered?

[BobBooth]

In the APP-06(B) standard, Search Area Reconnaissance (GFCPMGASS------) is specified like this:

Our Stylx matches the SIC (GFCPMGASS------) with this symbol, which can be used to draw both lines

As far as I can see, we have handled this the same way in 2525BC2 and 2525D implementations.
@csmoore - anything I'm missing?

[BobBooth]

@lfunkhouser - I checked in the style, we do offer a Left and Right version of the symbol.

[lfunkhouser]

Thanks @BobBooth

@csmoore verified that the AGOL item posted matches the latest updates in this repository. @topowright Can you confirm that the Pro team gets the stylx from the AGOL item?

[lfunkhouser]

Confirmed with @topowright that all passing of style items come from AGOL.