Buttons working on iOS + WEB + Desktop WhatsApp, but not for Android #650

brunoaduarte · 2024-08-28T21:08:21Z

brunoaduarte
Aug 28, 2024

Hi! Is there any secret to make a button message arrive on an Android device ?

My code does send a message button to all other 3 devices: iOS, Web and Windows Desktop successfully, but on Android receiver nothing appears on the chat.

It's strange though, because I tried a service that sends an OTP code to WhatsApp numbers (there's a copy button on the message) and the Android device received it.

Is anything wrong with my code?

I even tried to clone the entire message from the OTP example so it's exactly the same, even with that the message does not display.

FYI: I've tried mocking "TemplateID", "RecipientKeyHash", "RecipientKeyIndexes", "RecipientTimestamp" to the same as the message that arrived on the Android device (sent by the OTP service I've tested).

func (cli *Client) GetMessageWithButton(title, content, footer, buttonText string) *waE2E.Message {

	var hyderatedButtons []*waE2E.HydratedTemplateButton
	index := uint32(0)

	hyderatedButtons = append(hyderatedButtons, &waE2E.HydratedTemplateButton {
		Index: &index,
		HydratedButton: &waE2E.HydratedTemplateButton_UrlButton {
			UrlButton: &waE2E.HydratedTemplateButton_HydratedURLButton {
				DisplayText: proto.String(buttonText),
				URL: proto.String("https://www.whatsapp.com/otp/code/?otp_type=COPY_CODE&code_expiration_minutes=10&code=otp881320"),
			}}})

	timestamp, _ := strconv.ParseUint("1724818629", 10, 64)

	hydratedTemplate := &waE2E.TemplateMessage_HydratedFourRowTemplate {
		HydratedContentText: proto.String(content),
		HydratedFooterText:  proto.String(footer),
		HydratedButtons:     hyderatedButtons,
		TemplateID:          proto.String("4194019344155670"),
		Title: &waE2E.TemplateMessage_HydratedFourRowTemplate_HydratedTitleText {
			HydratedTitleText: proto.String(title),
		},
	}

	templateMessage := &waE2E.TemplateMessage {
		HydratedTemplate: hydratedTemplate,
		TemplateID: proto.String("4194019344155670"),
	}

	deviceListMetaData := &waE2E.DeviceListMetadata {
		RecipientKeyHash: []byte{}, // []byte{0xba, 0x35, 0xc5, 0x4d, 0xb1, 0x01, 0x3c, 0x62, 0xef, 0x44}
		RecipientTimestamp: &timestamp,
		RecipientKeyIndexes: []uint32{}, // []uint32{0, 15, 2}
	}

	messageContextinfo := &waE2E.MessageContextInfo{
		DeviceListMetadataVersion: proto.Int32(2),
		DeviceListMetadata: deviceListMetaData,
	}

	message := &waE2E.Message {
		TemplateMessage: templateMessage,
		MessageContextInfo: messageContextinfo,
	}

	// msgViewOnce := &waE2E.Message{
	// 	ViewOnceMessage: &waE2E.FutureProofMessage {
	// 		Message: message,
	// }}

	return message
}

buttonMessageTemplate := cli.GetMessageWithButton("", "Your verification code is *881320*.", "This code expires in 10 minutes.", "COPY CODE")
cli.SendMessage(context.Background(), cli.Store.ID.ToNonAD(), buttonMessageTemplate)

masewo · 2024-08-28T21:12:06Z

masewo
Aug 28, 2024

Since the latest changes from WhatsApp it should only be possible with the official WhatsApp Business API afaik.

2 replies

brunoaduarte Aug 28, 2024
Author

Yeah, I've seen this answers like these here since 2022, but it does not make sense, since it still works for iOS + Web + Desktop.

Also the message does arrive on the Android device (I can see it in the logs with Frida), it's just not displayed for some reason.

There must be a trick to make it work.

masewo Aug 28, 2024

Yea, not really logical but I guess they do an extra verification on Android devices. Whiskey stopped supporting it too.

a5r0n · 2024-08-30T10:40:42Z

a5r0n
Aug 30, 2024

@brunoaduarte
About the OTP service, if it's not an official bot, you could try to get the proto message and find any difference or tricks they use.

7 replies

brunoaduarte Sep 5, 2024
Author

@w3nder , i tried applying your structure to whatsmeow, but it din't worked. The message just appeared as a normal quoted message

func (cli *Client) GetButtons(title, content, footer, buttonText string) *waE2E.Message {
	msgVersion := int32(1)
	return &waE2E.Message {
		InteractiveMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage {
			Header: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Header {
				Title: proto.String(title),
				Subtitle: proto.String(content),
			},
			Footer: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Footer {
				Text: proto.String(footer),
			},
			Body: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Body {
				Text: proto.String(buttonText),
			},
			InteractiveMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_ {
				NativeFlowMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage {
					MessageVersion: &msgVersion,
					Buttons: []*waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_NativeFlowButton {
						{
							Name: proto.String("Yes"),
						},
						{
							Name: proto.String("No"),
						},
					},
				},
			},
			ContextInfo: &waE2E.ContextInfo {

			},
		},
	}
}

func (cli *Client) GetQuote(to types.JID, msgToQuote *waE2E.Message) *waE2E.Message {
	return &waE2E.Message {
		ExtendedTextMessage: &waE2E.ExtendedTextMessage {
			Text: proto.String(""),
			ContextInfo: &waE2E.ContextInfo {
				StanzaID: proto.String(""),
				Participant: proto.String(to.ToNonAD().String()),
				QuotedMessage: msgToQuote,
			},
		},
	}
}

to := types.NewJID("mynumber_xxxxxx", types.DefaultUserServer)
cli.SendMessage(context.Background(), to, cli.GetButtons("Title", "SubTitle", "Footer", "msg de botao"))
cli.SendMessage(context.Background(), to, cli.GetQuote(to, cli.GetButtons("Title", "SubTitle", "Footer", "msg de botao")))

And the result is

Any ideas?

w3nder Sep 5, 2024
Sponsor

We are able to send the buttons to Baileys in the way I mentioned.

Let me see how it looks in Meow.

Ased2235 Sep 5, 2024

We are able to send the buttons to Baileys in the way I mentioned.
Let me see how it looks in Meow.

Nevermind, it worked! Thanks!

Hello, Mind posting the full code which worked for you?

badlee Sep 5, 2024

We are able to send the buttons to Baileys in the way I mentioned.
Let me see how it looks in Meow.

Nevermind, it worked! Thanks!

@brunoaduarte, which code worked for you?

brunoaduarte Nov 14, 2024
Author

@w3nder the buttons doesn't work for iOS, nothing is received on the device. Is it working for you?

type InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_NativeFlowButton struct {
	state         protoimpl.MessageState
	sizeCache     protoimpl.SizeCache
	unknownFields protoimpl.UnknownFields

	Name             *string `protobuf:"bytes,1,opt,name=name" json:"name,omitempty"`
	ButtonParamsJSON *string `protobuf:"bytes,2,opt,name=buttonParamsJSON" json:"buttonParamsJSON,omitempty"`
}


func (cli *Client) GetButtons(title, content, footer string, buttonText []string) *waE2E.Message {

	var nativeFlowButtons []*waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_NativeFlowButton

	msgVersion := int32(1)
	deviceListMetadataVersion := int32(2)

        for _, button := range buttonText {

	            jsonData, _ := json.Marshal(ButtonParams{
		            DisplayText: button,
		            ID:          ".menu",
	            })
            
	            nativeFlowButtons = append(nativeFlowButtons, &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_NativeFlowButton{
		            Name:             proto.String("quick_reply"),
		            ButtonParamsJSON: proto.String(string(jsonData)),
	            })

        }

	return &waE2E.Message{
		InteractiveMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage{
			Header: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Header{
				Title:              proto.String(title),
				Subtitle:           proto.String(content),
				HasMediaAttachment: proto.Bool(false),
			},
			Footer: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Footer{
				Text: proto.String(footer),
			},
			Body: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Body{
				Text: proto.String(content),
			},
			InteractiveMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_{
				NativeFlowMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage{
					MessageVersion: &msgVersion,
					Buttons:        nativeFlowButtons,
				},
			},
			ContextInfo: &waE2E.ContextInfo{},
		},
		MessageContextInfo: &waE2E.MessageContextInfo{
			DeviceListMetadata:        &waE2E.DeviceListMetadata{},
			DeviceListMetadataVersion: &deviceListMetadataVersion,
		},
	}
}

cli.GetButtons("title", "content", "footer", []string{"button"}, nil)

BTW, if I comment

// Name:             proto.String("quick_reply"),

The message is received, but the button is empty

wxl2578 · 2024-10-08T13:01:29Z

wxl2578
Oct 8, 2024

Is there currently a code for the send button? In addition, when sending a template message, what is the message type and media type?

0 replies

hrizal · 2024-10-08T14:53:42Z

hrizal
Oct 8, 2024

at this time you cannot do that, i think meta filtered messages like that if coming from regular whatsapp. Pada Sel, 8 Okt 2024 pukul 20.01 Patricia C Stryker < ***@***.***> menulis:

…

Is there currently a code for the send button? In addition, when sending a template message, what is the message type and media type? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#650 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALJQY2EUYMRMXOZU2JJXI33Z2PJUJAVCNFSM6AAAAABNJC3RP2VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43URDJONRXK43TNFXW4Q3PNVWWK3TUHMYTAOBXHE4TINQ> . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

0 replies

f-amine · 2024-10-30T12:14:31Z

f-amine
Oct 30, 2024

any updates about this ? it works fine for android but not IOS for me

0 replies

hrizal · 2024-11-14T04:56:26Z

hrizal
Nov 14, 2024

No one its work since 2023 Pada Kam, 14 Nov 2024 10.47, Bruno Duarte ***@***.***> menulis:

…

@w3nder <https://github.com/w3nder> the buttons doesn't work for iOS, nothing is received on the device. Is it working for you? type InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_NativeFlowButton struct { state protoimpl.MessageState sizeCache protoimpl.SizeCache unknownFields protoimpl.UnknownFields Name *string `protobuf:"bytes,1,opt,name=name" json:"name,omitempty"` ButtonParamsJSON *string `protobuf:"bytes,2,opt,name=buttonParamsJSON" json:"buttonParamsJSON,omitempty"` } func (cli *Client) GetButtons(title, content, footer string, buttonText []string) *waE2E.Message { var nativeFlowButtons []*waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_NativeFlowButton msgVersion := int32(1) deviceListMetadataVersion := int32(2) for _, button := range buttonText { jsonData, _ := json.Marshal(ButtonParams{ DisplayText: button, ID: ".menu", }) nativeFlowButtons = append(nativeFlowButtons, &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_NativeFlowButton{ Name: proto.String("quick_reply"), ButtonParamsJSON: proto.String(string(jsonData)), }) } return &waE2E.Message{ InteractiveMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage{ Header: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Header{ Title: proto.String(title), Subtitle: proto.String(content), HasMediaAttachment: proto.Bool(false), }, Footer: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Footer{ Text: proto.String(footer), }, Body: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_Body{ Text: proto.String(content), }, InteractiveMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage_{ NativeFlowMessage: &waE2E.InteractiveMessage_NativeFlowMessage{ MessageVersion: &msgVersion, Buttons: nativeFlowButtons, }, }, ContextInfo: &waE2E.ContextInfo{}, }, MessageContextInfo: &waE2E.MessageContextInfo{ DeviceListMetadata: &waE2E.DeviceListMetadata{}, DeviceListMetadataVersion: &deviceListMetadataVersion, }, } } cli.GetButtons("title", "content", "footer", []string{"button"}, nil) BTW, if I comment // Name: proto.String("quick_reply"), The message is received, but the button is empty image.png (view on web) <https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/e96d127e-b151-4aaf-a2d2-8124c62d0f8d> — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#650 (reply in thread)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALJQY2HU3UE5OBU3YOH4XST2AQMLXAVCNFSM6AAAAABNJC3RP2VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43URDJONRXK43TNFXW4Q3PNVWWK3TUHMYTCMRUHEYDGMY> . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: ***@***.***>

0 replies

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Buttons working on iOS + WEB + Desktop WhatsApp, but not for Android #650

{{title}}

{{editor}}'s edit

{{editor}}'s edit

Replies: 6 comments 9 replies

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{editor}}'s edit

{{editor}}'s edit

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{editor}}'s edit

{{editor}}'s edit

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

Select a reply

Buttons working on iOS + WEB + Desktop WhatsApp, but not for Android #650

Replies: 6 comments · 9 replies

brunoaduarte Aug 28, 2024 Author

brunoaduarte Sep 5, 2024 Author

w3nder Sep 5, 2024 Sponsor

brunoaduarte Nov 14, 2024 Author

Replies: 6 comments 9 replies

brunoaduarte Aug 28, 2024
Author

brunoaduarte Sep 5, 2024
Author

w3nder Sep 5, 2024
Sponsor

brunoaduarte Nov 14, 2024
Author