Leaderboards with bad score ordering

[Walavouchey]

was told this was mentioned in the meeting chat right when the issue was brought up

Kurokotei - Galaxy Collapse [Galactic]

[WitherFlower]

Here are the main issues of scoring in its current state. Hope this helps giving somewhat of a path forward.

Issues with scorev1 :

• FCs aren't ordered by acc because acc depends on where you dropped 100s (aka "getting scorev1'd")

  • Cases where it's noticeable : literally every leaderboard in the game. Just press F2 and you'll find a case of this
  • This is solved by SV2

• Combo has too much importance compared to acc

  • Cases where it's noticeable : leaderboards with few or no FCs, like https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/396221#osu/862088 (see n°1 vs n°2 on the map), and tournaments
  • This is solved by SV2

• Missing in the middle of the map is too punishing

  • Cases where it's noticeable : this one is mostly felt by experienced tournament players / players that use SV2 a lot. I suggested in the meeting's chat that we should ask tournament players how they feel about this to make sure it's a good direction.
  • This is solved by Modify osu! standardised scoring to introduce a combo exponent  #24166

Issues with standardised scoring :

• Bonus portion depends on the number of bonus objects in the map
  • Cases where it's noticeable : marathon maps with a lot of spinners, like this one https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/121591#osu/311269, where the bonus score can reach above 100k points in current lazer scoring
  • This is currently not addressed but a solution was debated earlier in this channel

[Zyfarok]

to "Issues with standardised scoring" I would also add:

• slider-ends have way too little value. They had much more impact in scorev1 and v2 since they gave 1 combo and not aiming them properly would turn the slider into a 100. There value is currently 10 in lazer but should probably be at least 100, if not 200. (By comparison, slider-ticks only give 30 points, but they give 1 combo which makes them much more important)
  This issue is being tracket here: Reconsider scoring of SmallTick / LargeTick #23403

It's not directly about the scoring formula, but it's highly related.