diff --git a/perllib/FixMyStreet/Cobrand/Bexley.pm b/perllib/FixMyStreet/Cobrand/Bexley.pm
index 2032c96ec3f..77af3076660 100644
--- a/perllib/FixMyStreet/Cobrand/Bexley.pm
+++ b/perllib/FixMyStreet/Cobrand/Bexley.pm
@@ -216,6 +216,8 @@ sub open311_post_send {
     my $emails = $self->feature('open311_email') || return;
     my $dangerous = $row->get_extra_field_value('dangerous') || '';
 
+    my $is_out_of_hours = _is_out_of_hours();
+
     my $p1_email = 0;
     my $outofhours_email = 0;
     if ($row->category eq 'Abandoned and untaxed vehicles') {
@@ -251,7 +253,9 @@ sub open311_post_send {
         if ($blocking eq 'Yes' || $hazardous eq 'Yes') {
             $outofhours_email = 1;
         }
-        $p1_email = 1;
+        if (!$is_out_of_hours || ($blocking eq 'Yes' && $hazardous eq 'Yes')) {
+            $p1_email = 1;
+        }
     } elsif ($row->category eq 'Alleyway') { #FlytippingAlleyway
         $p1_email = 1 if $dangerous eq 'Yes';
     } elsif ($row->category eq 'Obstructions on pavements and roads') {
@@ -278,7 +282,7 @@ sub open311_post_send {
     push @to, email_list($p1_email_to_use, 'Bexley P1 email') if $p1_email;
     push @to, email_list($emails->{lighting}, 'FixMyStreet Bexley Street Lighting') if $lighting{$row->category};
     push @to, email_list($emails->{flooding}, 'FixMyStreet Bexley Flooding') if $flooding{$row->category};
-    push @to, email_list($emails->{outofhours}, 'Bexley out of hours') if $outofhours_email && _is_out_of_hours();
+    push @to, email_list($emails->{outofhours}, 'Bexley out of hours') if $outofhours_email && $is_out_of_hours;
     if ($contact->email =~ /^Uniform/) {
         push @to, email_list($emails->{eh}, 'FixMyStreet Bexley EH');
         $row->push_extra_fields({ name => 'uniform_id', description => 'Uniform ID', value => $row->external_id });
diff --git a/t/cobrand/bexley.t b/t/cobrand/bexley.t
index aec34961a63..76298498ac1 100644
--- a/t/cobrand/bexley.t
+++ b/t/cobrand/bexley.t
@@ -149,9 +149,15 @@ FixMyStreet::override_config {
             extra => { 'name' => 'dangerous', description => 'Was it dangerous?', 'value' => 'Yes' } },
         { category => 'Flytipping', code => 'UniformFLY', email => ['eh'] },
         { category => 'Graffiti', code => 'GRAF', email => ['p1'], extra => { 'name' => 'offensive', description => 'Is the graffiti racist or offensive?', 'value' => 'Yes' } },
-        { category => 'Carriageway', code => 'CARRIAGEWAY', email => ['p1'] },
-        { category => 'Carriageway', code => 'CARRIAGEWAY', email => ['p1', 'outofhours', 'ooh2'],
+        { category => 'Carriageway', code => 'CARRIAGEWAY', },
+        { category => 'Carriageway', code => 'CARRIAGEWAY', email => ['outofhours', 'ooh2'],
             extra => { 'name' => 'blocking', description => 'Flytipping blocking carriageway?', 'value' => 'Yes' } },
+        { category => 'Carriageway', code => 'CARRIAGEWAY', email => ['p1', 'outofhours', 'ooh2'],
+            extra => [
+                { 'name' => 'blocking', description => 'Flytipping blocking carriageway?', 'value' => 'Yes' },
+                { 'name' => 'hazardous', value => 'Yes' },
+            ],
+        },
         { category => 'Obstructions on pavements and roads', code => 'OBSTR', email => ['p1'],
             extra => { 'name' => 'reportType', description => 'Type of obstruction?', 'value' => 'Tables and Chairs' } },
         { category => 'Obstructions on pavements and roads', code => 'OBSTR', email => ['p1', 'outofhours', 'ooh2'],