-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 97
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Curtain Status stuck on opening or closing #143
Comments
Good catch, thanks for the report! Could you add the api output as requested in the issue template? |
Hello - the curtain device is VERY welcome - thank you! However, I think I have the same (similar?) issue. When the curtains are open, the switch in HomeKit shows 'Open' but when they are closed, the switch endlessly shows as 'Closing'. Thanks. |
same here, if also include percentage control it will be much welcomed thanks. |
Hello, could you please trying installing the latest pre-release version and see if that fixes the problem for you. How to install a pre-release version. |
Hi Milo I've installed the pre-release version and can confirm that this now appears to be fixed, for me at least. Many thanks! |
I upgraded to version v0.7.1 and it always appears to me that the curtain is open now. I click the button to close, but after a while the button appears as open. |
@edmarts cool, but how about the pre-release? 😛 you will need to install version |
After installing the pre-release v0.8.0-0, in Homekit my 3 roller shade covers are showing either (Closing...) when the shades are already closed, or (Opening...) when the shades are already open. If the Shades are closed and I close out of and reopen Homekit, the (Closing...) status automatically changes to (Opening...). Below is the log right after restarting Homekit. Maybe it will help?
Also in homebridge it shows the shade accessory at 50% open. |
If you open the Home app 15 minutes after you closed the roller shades, do they still show as closing? Or are they then properly shown as closed? |
Hi, I think I might have spoken too soon on my previous message. As far as I can tell, the button now performs correctly when I press it manually in the HomeKit app (which it didn't previously), however if the curtains are closed by a HomeKit automation (as happens for me every evening) it still seems to stick at 'Closing...' indefinately (though the curtains do physically close properly). I will keep an eye on it again and report if this was just a blip for some reason the last time the automation ran. |
It is never ending for me. |
Me too 😔 |
Hello, unfortunetelly, i have same issue. What i did is:
Means, i can not control the curtain. For some reason when i press the button in homekit multiple times, the curtain will open. But this is more or less coincidence. Any idea about that? Here is some output of my protocol: [7.1.2021, 08:33:04] [TuyaWebPlatform] [Vorhangschalter] - Unsetting debouncedDeviceStateRequestPromise |
I installed the version v0.8.0-0 but the issue still. In version v0.7.1, one of the curtains always appears as open and the other always appears as closed, but in version v0.8.0-0 the curtains still showing the message "opening" or "closing" or if they are open show "50% opened" ... the v0.7.1 is more stable |
So I don't know what is wrong here, since I don't yet own a Tuya cover device, it is hard for me to debug this. I will put this issue "on-hold" until I acquire such a device or somebody is able to fix this through a pull-request. |
Would it be possible to provide such a device so that you can implement this? |
That is always an option (and a very welcome one), however in this case it is an option that is already put in motion. If this plugin helps you and you want to ensure its continued development you are very welcome to donate, see the donation options on the homepage. |
Hey Same problem :-( |
@alanit0 |
UPDATE: Never mind about 10 minutes later they are back to saying closing. |
Hey guys. What is “funny” is that if they are actually closed, I issue the “open” command in HomeKit and they open right away, but if they are actually open with a status of closed, I touch the button to order then to open (since the status in HomeKit is closed but the shutters are open, I mind you) homekit changes status to “opening “ for a dozen seconds and then status change to “open” for 30 seconds or so, then HomeKit changes status to close again. If I touch the HomeKit button 2 times, the shutters close as supposed to. The strange thing is that this only started to happen after I installed more than 1 controller, when I only had 1 single controller in the house, the controller status would be accurate, status as opened when open and closed when closed. Other than that, they work great, even with automations. They open on sunrise and close on sundown perfectly, regardless of the HomeKit status. btw, I’m on 0.7 |
I'm seeing the same behaviour as @edmarts in
I did test the hold position switch in I'm using one of these blind chain motors. |
Just to note that I've tried version 0.8.0-0 and for some reason the behaviour of my controllers is even worst, now when I send an order it still closes and opens but the status is always on "opening" and then eventually gets "not responding". I've returned to 0.7.1 and it's better. |
@milo526 , |
Sadly not, I have not yet received a request from bsr43 to merge this. |
Hello, Sorry for delay, I was not looking at the repo and all notifications are disabled on my side 😅 |
Would be great to see the fix from bSr43/homebridge-tuya-web@91ef52e in the next version as I'm struggling with the same issue. |
Also, related to #148, I can see that bSr43@91ef52e includes percentage values in theory allowing curtains to stay ajar (half-open), however even with bSr43's fork I cannot get curtain to 50% open. Wondering whose fault is it, homekit or tuya or..? And whether it's fixable at all. |
Any progress on this one? Should I create a PR from @bSr43's fork? I just encountered #161 while on that fork, not sure it's Tuya's problem or the fork's... want to switch to @milo526's one, but w/o bSr43@91ef52e this will render my curtains non-functional. |
I have very little time to develop this library further until the end of this year, please do not expect any release until that time. |
I have the same problem with the Wifi curtain motor model BCM700D WiFi |
hi I have the latest version, I used the IOT Tuya platform, loading the Secret Key and everything with the tuya plugin on home bridge. There, everything worked well. The thing is that Tuya IoT platform is payed (pretty expensive for home use) and the 1 month free trial has ended. Now Using @milo526 plugin, it exposes the curtains pretty well, but mainly two issues. The curtains have a lag on the status (closing or opening, when already reached the closing/open point) and also there is no way to make the curtains half open or on a partial closing/opening point. As I said, I am running latest plugin version. Thank @milo526 for the plugin. |
Fix for a similar issue for official tuya plugin: tuya/tuya-homebridge#363 |
Hi @milo526 ! How are you? |
Hey @zico202020, would you be able to share how you’ve got this working? |
Got the exact same issue since i'm using home bridge. In home bridge, the curtain seems to be at 50% everytime. |
Have an issue with the curtain. @milo526 It’s showing on the home app. But it can only open. Can’t close. Please help. |
I think this project is sort of dead. You better try another plugin. |
What plugin can you recommend? |
I use the plugin homebridge-tuya-web (https://github.com/bsr43/homebridge-tuya-web#readme). You need an account for it, but it works good. |
Ok, but then I do not get the point:
Last commit there is 4 years ago and the plugin was forked from milo526/homebridge-tuya-web |
@bSr43 can u pls help. Loaded but curtain not working. It’s showing as icon in HomeKit. |
I'm sorry, but like I previously said here a few years ago, I'm not using these devices anymore. I switched to Meross which worked perfectly fine for the last two years. Sorry for not being able to help. |
Is there a way to fund you to speed things up regarding the fix from bSr43@91ef52e ? |
I'd rather see someone making a PR and working with me to fix this. |
@bSr43 Could you please send a PR for bSr43/homebridge-tuya-web@91ef52e ?
I think there are more then enough people here willing to test this. ;-) |
|
Hi - Just jumping into this home bridge-tuya thing. My curtains are exhibiting what's been discussed here. with my curtains wide open, Homebridge shows 50%. tuya smart app reports 0% (Fully open). Apple home is stuck in an "Opening" Status. Position State on the accessory always stays at "2". whether they are opened or closed. The curtains seem controllable in apple home and home bridge. For instance when I click the curtain (shown in home bridge at 50%) it closes (tile goes dark but still reports 50%). Apple home reports "closing". but never closed. Then when I click the home bridge icon to open, It opens Goes light again and apple home reports opening. but never sets the state as "opened". But would love to know if there is a fix for this. |
Having the same exact issue as described above, I have this type of Wifi motors for curtains https://cnwstele.en.made-in-china.com/product/BOWavTiFrgVP/China-Tuya-Smart-Curtain-Motor-Bt-Voice-Control-Electric-Curtain-Robot.html In the Tuya Developer Platform I can see this in device debug:
Maybe this will be helpful |
Did anyone managed to get a PR in place with a fix for this? Would be great to get this resolved as it has been open issue since 2020 |
I have not seen any such PR. |
You should have received a PR now. #618 |
I've seen this also on my smart blinds |
I have a problem with the curtains (Zemismart).
In the homebridge they always appear as if they have 50%, even though they are already open. When I click, it appears as 100% open. (image 1)
In the homekit it appears as closed and with the spin thinking. I have to click on it to appear as open, but it is already open. (image 2)
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: