diff --git a/packages/garbo/src/familiar/freeFightFamiliar.ts b/packages/garbo/src/familiar/freeFightFamiliar.ts
index cbc82f964..d10f79384 100644
--- a/packages/garbo/src/familiar/freeFightFamiliar.ts
+++ b/packages/garbo/src/familiar/freeFightFamiliar.ts
@@ -9,20 +9,18 @@ import {
   $familiar,
   $item,
   $location,
-  $phylum,
   clamp,
   findLeprechaunMultiplier,
   get,
   getModifier,
   have,
-  Snapper,
 } from "libram";
 import { canOpenRedPresent } from ".";
 import { garboValue } from "../garboValue";
 import getConstantValueFamiliars from "./constantValueFamiliars";
 import getDropFamiliars from "./dropFamiliars";
 import getExperienceFamiliars from "./experienceFamiliars";
-import { GeneralFamiliar, timeToMeatify } from "./lib";
+import { GeneralFamiliar, snapperValue, timeToMeatify } from "./lib";
 import { meatFamiliar } from "./meatFamiliar";
 import { gooseDroneEligible, valueDrops } from "../lib";
 import { globalOptions } from "../config";
@@ -102,25 +100,9 @@ export function menu(
         ? !["Macrometeorite", "Powerful Glove"].includes(fight)
         : true
     ) {
-      const item = Snapper.phylumItem.get(globalOptions.target.phylum);
-      // Special handling for penguin envelopes
-      const itemValue =
-        globalOptions.target.phylum === $phylum`Penguin`
-          ? 25_000
-          : item
-            ? garboValue(item)
-            : 0;
-
       familiarMenu.push({
         familiar: $familiar`Red-Nosed Snapper`,
-        expectedValue:
-          copyTargetCount() >
-          11 -
-            (Snapper.getTrackedPhylum() === globalOptions.target.phylum
-              ? Snapper.getProgress()
-              : 0)
-            ? itemValue
-            : 0,
+        expectedValue: snapperValue(),
         leprechaunMultiplier: 0,
         limit: "special",
       });
diff --git a/packages/garbo/src/familiar/lib.ts b/packages/garbo/src/familiar/lib.ts
index 7d33bfa44..4b9f4c94a 100644
--- a/packages/garbo/src/familiar/lib.ts
+++ b/packages/garbo/src/familiar/lib.ts
@@ -14,11 +14,13 @@ import {
   clamp,
   get,
   have,
+  Snapper,
   sumNumbers,
 } from "libram";
 import { globalOptions } from "../config";
 import { baseMeat, ESTIMATED_OVERDRUNK_TURNS, turnsToNC } from "../lib";
 import { digitizedMonstersRemaining, estimatedGarboTurns } from "../turns";
+import { garboValue } from "../garboValue";
 
 export type GeneralFamiliar = {
   familiar: Familiar;
@@ -131,3 +133,13 @@ export function estimatedBarfExperience(): number {
 
   return sumNumbers(sources);
 }
+
+const ESTIMATED_ENVELOPE_VALUE = 25_000;
+
+export function snapperValue(): number {
+  const item = Snapper.phylumItem.get(globalOptions.target.phylum);
+  if (!item) return 0;
+
+  if (item === $item`envelope full of Meat`) return ESTIMATED_ENVELOPE_VALUE;
+  return garboValue(item);
+}