-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 0
/
01-intro.Rmd
43 lines (26 loc) · 3.41 KB
/
01-intro.Rmd
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
```{r include = FALSE}
if(!knitr:::is_html_output())
{
options("width"=56)
knitr::opts_chunk$set(tidy.opts=list(width.cutoff=56, indent = 2), tidy = TRUE)
knitr::opts_chunk$set(fig.pos = 'ht')
}
```
# Introduction
AGEC-LCI is a VBA application hosted in Microsoft Excel that computes emissions generated from the application of soil amendments, fertilizers and metal-based fungicides in agriculture (Figure \@ref(fig:agec-lci-emissions)).
```{r agec-lci-emissions,echo=FALSE,out.width="95%",fig.align='center',fig.cap="Emissions Computed by AGEC-LCI"}
knitr::include_graphics("Figures/agec_lci_emissions.png")
```
A state of the art analysis of the models for computing direct field emission from fertilizers, pesticides and soil amendments was carried out. Acknowledging that agricultural emissions are site- and time dependent, a parsimonious approach was considered for the selection of the models (Table \@ref(tab:agec-models)). See [Section](#selected-methods) \@ref(selected-methods) for more details on the selected models.
Table: (\#tab:agec-models) Selected models for calculating agricultural emissions and comparison with LCI databases
|Emission|![](Figures/agri-footprint.png) [agri footprint](https://www.agri-footprint.com/){target="_blank"} [@durlinger2017]|![](Figures/ecoinvent.png) [ecoinvent v3](https://www.ecoinvent.org/){target="_blank"} [@nemecek2011]|![](Figures/agribalyse.png) [AGRIBALYSE ®](https://www.ademe.fr/en/expertise/alternative-approaches-to-production/agribalyse-program){target="_blank"} [@Koch2015]|![](Figures/WFLDB.png) [WFLDB](https://quantis-intl.com/tools/databases/wfldb-food/){target="_blank"} [@nemecek2014]|![](Figures/agec_lci_logo.png) AGEC-LCI|
|------------|----------------|------------|-------------|------------|-----------------|
|Ammonia (NH~3~)|IPCC (2006)|Agrammon (Tier 3 methodology for Switzerland)|EMEP Tier 2 (EEA 2009)|EMEP Tier 2 (EEA 2013)|EMEP Tier 2 (EEA 2009 & EEA 2013)|
|Nitrous oxide (N~2~O)|IPCC (2006)|IPCC (2006) crops: Tier 1 animals: Tier 2|IPCC (2006) crops: Tier 1 animals: Tier 2|IPCC (2006) crops: Tier 1 animals: Tier 2|"IPCC (2006) crops: Tier 1^(a)^|
|Nitrate (NO~3~^-^)|IPCC (2006)|Europe: SALCA-Nitrate (Richner et al. 2014), Other countries: SQCB (Faist et al, 2009)|Annual French crops: COMIFER 2001 adjusted (Tailleur et al. 2012),Permanent crops: SQCB (Faist et al, 2009)|Europe: SALCA-Nitrate (Richner et al. 2014), Other countries: SQCB (Faist et al, 2009)|SQCB (Faist et al, 2009)|
|Phosphorus (P,PO~4~^3-^)|(Struijs, Beusen, Zwart, & Huijbregts, 2011)|SALCA-P (Prasuhn, 2006)|SALCA-P (Prasuhn, 2006)|SALCA-P (Prasuhn, 2006)|SALCA-P (Prasuhn, 2006)|SALCA-P (Prasuhn, 2006)|
|Heavy metals (Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, Ni, Pb, Zn)|(Mels et al., 2008, Romkens & Rietra, 2008, Nemecek & Schnetzer, 2012)|SALCA method (Freiermuth, 2006)|SALCA method (Freiermuth, 2006)|SALCA method (Freiermuth, 2006)|SALCA method (Freiermuth, 2006)|
|Methane (CH~4~)|Dutch National Inventory Reports|IPCC (2006) Tier 2|IPCC (2006) Tier 2|IPCC (2006) Tier 2|-|
|Synthetic pesticides|100 % of the substance emitted to agricultural soil|100 % of the substance emitted to agricultural soil|100 % of the substance emitted to agricultural soil|100 % of the substance emitted to soil^(b)^|-|
(a): The AGEC-LCI tool does not compute enteric emissions of livestock.
(b): Rule followed in the first and second release of the WFLDB. The third release will follow the rules defined in Glasgow workshops [@nemecek2014].