Allow RayCast to report collisions through multiple objects

[TheHyper-Dev]

Describe the project you are working on

I'm working on an FPS game where I'm trying to implement bullet penetration, I'm in desperate need for a method that counterparts the RaycastAll() method from Unity. I need multiple hit infos.

Describe the problem or limitation you are having in your project

Raycast only hitting one object and stopping.

Describe the feature / enhancement and how it helps to overcome the problem or limitation

it's pretty self explanatory

Describe how your proposal will work, with code, pseudo-code, mock-ups, and/or diagrams

You already have ShapeCast that gets multiple hits, perhaps using a shape like a SeparationRayShape3D would do the trick but please, we need something more proper.

If this enhancement will not be used often, can it be worked around with a few lines of script?

the answer is given above

Is there a reason why this should be core and not an add-on in the asset library?

it is a fundamental raycasting option

[Calinou]

Moving to discussions, as there is no concrete technical implementation provided.

You already have ShapeCast that gets multiple hits, perhaps using a shape like a SeparationRayShape3D would do the trick but please, we need something more proper.

I think documenting the current approach would go a long way 🙂

That said, in other engines, this is usually implemented by performing raycasts iteratively (i.e. perform a second raycast behind the first one if a collision is reported). The same can be achieved in Godot with scripting.

[smix8]

You can do that in Godot with scripts and a simple loop.

Use the PhysicsDirectSpaceState3D.intersect_ray() function and update the used PhysicsRayQueryParameters3D before every raycast by adding the RID from the previously hit collider to the 'exclude' array of the parameters.

[krisutofu]

If anyone comes here for the same problem:
Iteratively casting rays by moving the ray forwards does not work with Godot (except your shapes are sufficently displaced) and I had to figure it out by trying it with multiple methods. It required me more than one full day of work to get it done which I actually would have needed to implement missing features for my close project deadline.

In my case, I try to detect if a player walks across one of multiple arbitrary polygons on the ground whose convex hulls are overlapping a lot.

Small Ray displacement does not work. Maybe Godot deliberately sets the ray's starting point a little back. In any case, the previous collision is found again even though it shouldn't be. The result is non-deterministic. The probability is good when standing or moving slowly but when moving fast, the iteration doesn't work well.

The only working way is what smix8 describes, using the PhysicsRayQueryParameters3D.Exclude property with GetWorld3D().DirectSpaceState.IntersectRay() in C#. It can only be used during the _PhysicsProcess call. RIDs cannot be added directly to the Exclude Property (I assume, it returns a copy) and it needs to be set to a new array in every cycle. This loop would be a very good generator in the API (if GDScript has the same kind of Generators like C#).

I tried to use TestMove iteratively but this doesn't work, it has no options to exclude collsion objects or choose a collision mask. It might not even find multiple collisions when the polygons are lying in the same plane.