From e8d5a82a4fb3da82c65acd1395a93f390540d582 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: =?UTF-8?q?Christoph=20M=C3=BCllner?= Date: Tue, 8 Nov 2022 00:07:10 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] Define `-march` string MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit This is essentially a collection of all recent change requests for the -march string: * Relax the ISA string order ([1]) * Add custom extensions ([2]) * Add profiles support ([3]) Most of this patch is based on proposals from Kito Cheng (see linked resources below). [1] https://github.com/riscv-non-isa/riscv-toolchain-conventions/pull/14 [2] https://github.com/riscv-non-isa/riscv-toolchain-conventions/issues/1 [3] https://lists.riscv.org/g/sig-toolchains/message/379 [4] https://github.com/riscv-non-isa/riscv-toolchain-conventions/issues/11 Signed-off-by: Christoph Müllner --- README.mkd | 156 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--------- 1 file changed, 130 insertions(+), 26 deletions(-) diff --git a/README.mkd b/README.mkd index e215b20..dcfb4f0 100644 --- a/README.mkd +++ b/README.mkd @@ -47,34 +47,138 @@ Manual](https://github.com/riscv-non-isa/riscv-asm-manual/blob/master/riscv-asm. * [GCC RISC-V option documentation](https://gcc.gnu.org/onlinedocs/gcc/RISC-V-Options.html) -## Specifying the target ISA with -march - -The compiler and assembler both accept the `-march` flag to specify the target -ISA, e.g. `rv32imafd`. The abbreviation `g` can be used to represent either -`IMAFD` (when targeting RISC-V ISA specification version 2.2 or earlier) or -`IMAFD_Zicsr_Zifencei` (version 20190608 or later) base and extensions, -e.g. `-march=rv64g`. A target `-march` which includes floating point -instructions implies a hardfloat calling convention, but can be overridden -using the `-mabi` flag (see the next section). - -The ISA subset naming conventions are described in Chapter 27 of the RISC-V -user-level ISA specification. However, tools do not currently follow this -specification (input is case sensitive, ...). - -If the 'C' (compressed) instruction set extension is targeted, the compiler +## Specifying the target ISA with `-march` and `-misa-spec` + +The compiler and assembler both accept the `-march` flag to specify the target +ISA. Additionally, the `-misa-spec` flag allows specifying the ISA specification +release, which can have a subtle difference on how the string provided to the +`-march` flag is interpreted. + +The `-march` string can be defined using one of the following formats: +1) using the ISA-string-based format, or +2) using the profile-based format. + +Both formats allow specifying a list of extensions that form an additive set. + +### ISA-string-based format + +The ISA-string-based format looks similar to ISA naming strings as specified +in the ISA Extension Naming Conventions chapter of the RISC-V ISA +specification. + +A valid `-march` string in the ISA-string-based format must follow these rules: + +* All characters of the string must be lowercase. +* The first part of the string must be `rv32`, `rv64`, or `rv128` followed by + the base integer ISA (`i`, or `e`). As `g` implies `i`, this letter can + also be used. +* The next part consists of single-letter ISA extensions, which may be in + non-canonical order. +* The next part consists of multi-letter ISA extensions, which may be in + non-canonical order. +* Single-letter ISA extensions are separated from the multi-letter extension + by an underscore (`_`). +* Multi-letter extensions are separated by an underscore (`_`). +* Versioning of extensions follows the ISA naming string rules (e.g. `zba1p0`). + Single-letter extensions with versioning are still considered single-letter + extensions (`m1p0` is considered a single-letter extension). +* Version separator(`p`) has a higher priority than a trailing `p` in the + extension name. E.g. `zba1p` will be interpreted as `zba` version 1.0 and + not as `zba1p`. + +Examples: + +* `rv32imac`: Valid `-march` string. +* `rv64gc`: Valid ISA string. +* `rv32ima_zicsr`: Valid `-march` string. +* `rv32i2p1m2p0a2p1f2p2d2p2c_zicsr_zifencei`: Valid `-march` string. +* `rv64gc_zba_zbb_zbc1p0`: Valid `-march` string. +* `rv64gc_xtheadba`: Valid `-march` string. +* `rv64gc_Zicsr`: Invalid because of the uppercase character. +* `rv32mai`: Invalid because base ISA does not follow `rv32`. +* `rv32i_zicsr_m`: Invalid because `m` after multi-letter extension. +* `rv32i_zicsrzifencei`: Invalid because multi-letter extensions need to be + separated by an underscore (`zicsr` and `zifencei` are existing individual + extensions). + +NOTE: The ISA-string-based format is a user-friendly format, +that is different from the machine-friendly format in the ELF +tag `Tag_RISCV_arch`. + +#### Interpretation versioning with `-misa-spec` + +The interpretation of the string provided to the `-march` flag +in ISA-string-based format is versioned using the `-misa-spec` flag. +The `-misa-spec` flag is incompatible with a string provided +to the `-march` flag in the profile-based format. + +Possible versions are: + +* `2.2` +* `20190608` +* `20191213` + +Additional versions might appear in the future if a change of +the interpretation is required. + +The following interpretation differences exist: + +* The expansion of `g` with versions before `20190609` is `imafd`. + The expansion of `g` with version `20190609` or later is + `imafd_zicsr_zifencei`. + +Examples: + +* `-march=rv64gc -misa-spec=20191213` enables RV64I and the extensions + `mafdc` as well as `zicsr` and `zifencei`. +* `-march=rv64gc -misa-spec=rva22` is invalid (unknown ISA version). + +NOTE: The RISC-V specification is intended to be backward and +forward-compatible. However, such a goal is usually hard to achieve and fixes +for mistakes in specifications or misinterpretation of specifications +may require differences in how the `-march` string is interpreted. +The required changes are subtle and irrelevant to most users. +However, a mechanism to enable old behavior (even if considered wrong) +is considered a helpful solution for users that depend on this behavior. + +### Profile-based format + +The profiles-string-based format has the following form +`-march=[+]+`. + +Profile names are lowercase strings of the profile name (e.g. `rva22u64`). +It is possible to add additional extensions using the `+` character. + +The effect of specifying a profile is that all mandatory extensions +of that profile will be enabled. The list of mandatory extensions +of a profile can be found in the RISC-V profiles specification. + +The profiles-string-based format is implicitly versioned +by the profile's prefix (e.g. "rva22"), therefore a change in the +interpretation (if necessary) can be introduced by adding support +for a new profile version. Therefore, the profiles-string-based format +is not compatible with the versioning flag `-misa-spec`. + +Examples: + +* `rva22u64`: Valid `-march` string. +* `rva22u64+v` Valid `-march` string. +* `rva22u64+xtheadba`: Valid `-march` string. +* `rva22u64+xventanacondopts1p0`: Valid -march string. +* `RVA22U64`: Invalid because the string must not contain uppercase characters. +* `rva22u64+zfinx` is not valid because Zfinx is incompatible with RVA22U64. +* `-march=rva22u64 -misa-spec=2.2` is not valid because the `-misa-spec` + flag is not compatible with the profile-based format. + +### Implicit effects of the `-march` string + +A target `-march` string, which includes floating point instructions, implies a +hardfloat calling convention, but can be overridden using the `-mabi` flag +(see the next section). + +If the `c` (compressed) instruction set extension is targeted, the compiler will generate compressed instructions where possible. -### Issues for consideration -* Whether `riscv32` and `riscv64` should be accepted as synonyms for `rv32` -and `rv64`. -* Whether the `-march` string should be parsed case insensitively. -* Exposing the ability to specify version numbers for a target extension. -* Specifying non-standard extensions. The ISA specification suggests naming -such as `rv32gXfirstext_Xsecondext`. In GCC or Clang it would be more -conventional to give a string such as `rv32g+firstext+secondext`. -* Whether ordering should be enforced on the ISA string (e.g. currently -`rv32imafd` is accepted by GCC but `rv32iamfd` is not). - ## Specifying the target ABI with -mabi RISC-V compilers support the following ABIs, which can be specified using