Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
[#12995] Create documentation for unit tests (#12996)
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
* Create documentation for unit tests

* Update docs/unit-testing.md

Co-authored-by: Zhang Ziqing <[email protected]>

* Update docs/unit-testing.md

Co-authored-by: Zhang Ziqing <[email protected]>

---------

Co-authored-by: Zhang Ziqing <[email protected]>
  • Loading branch information
cedricongjh and ziqing26 authored Apr 8, 2024
1 parent 84ed244 commit db0fd94
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Showing 3 changed files with 212 additions and 1 deletion.
1 change: 1 addition & 0 deletions docs/_markbind/layouts/default.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -27,6 +27,7 @@
* [Captcha]({{ baseUrl }}/captcha.html)
* [Documentation]({{ baseUrl }}/documentation.html)
* [Emails]({{ baseUrl }}/emails.html)
* [Unit Testing]({{ baseUrl }}/unit-testing.html)
* [End-to-End Testing]({{ baseUrl }}/e2e-testing.html)
* [Performance Testing]({{ baseUrl }}/performance-testing.html)
* [Accessibility Testing]({{ baseUrl }}/axe-testing.html)
Expand Down
6 changes: 5 additions & 1 deletion docs/development.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -291,7 +291,9 @@ There are two big categories of testing in TEAMMATES:
- **Component tests**: white-box unit and integration tests, i.e. they test the application components with full knowledge of the components' internal workings. This is configured in `src/test/resources/testng-component.xml` (back-end) and `src/web/jest.config.js` (front-end).
- **E2E (end-to-end) tests**: black-box tests, i.e. they test the application as a whole without knowing any internal working. This is configured in `src/e2e/resources/testng-e2e.xml`. To learn more about E2E tests, refer to this [document](e2e-testing.md).

#### Running the tests
<div id="running-tests">

#### Running tests

##### Frontend tests

Expand Down Expand Up @@ -335,6 +337,8 @@ You can generate the coverage data with `jacocoReport` task after running tests,
The report can be found in the `build/reports/jacoco/jacocoReport/` directory.
</div>
## Deploying to a staging server
> `Staging server` is the server instance you set up on Google App Engine for hosting the app for testing purposes.
Expand Down
206 changes: 206 additions & 0 deletions docs/unit-testing.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,206 @@
<frontmatter>
title: "Unit Testing"
</frontmatter>

# Unit Testing

## What is Unit Testing?

Unit testing is a testing methodology where the objective is to test components in isolation.

- It aims to ensure all components of the application work as expected, assuming its dependencies are working.
- This is done in TEAMMATES by using mocks to simulate a component's dependencies.

Frontend Unit tests in TEAMMATES are located in `.spec.ts` files, while Backend Unit tests in TEAMMATES can be found in the package `teammates.test`.


## Writing Unit Tests

### General guidelines

#### Include only relevant details in tests
When writing unit tests, reduce the amount of noise in the code to make it easier for future developers to follow.

The code below has a lot of noise in creation of the `studentModel`:

```javascript
it('displayInviteButton: should display "Send Invite" button when a student has not joined the course', () => {
component.studentModels = [
{
student: {
name: 'tester',
teamName: 'Team 1',
email: '[email protected]',
joinState: JoinState.NOT_JOINED,
sectionName: 'Tutorial Group 1',
courseId: 'text-exa.demo',
},
isAllowedToViewStudentInSection: true,
isAllowedToModifyStudent: true,
},
];

expect(sendInviteButton).toBeTruthy();
});
```

However, what is important is only the student joinState. We should thus reduce the noise by including only the relevant details:

```javascript
it('displayInviteButton: should display "Send Invite" button when a student has not joined the course', () => {
component.studentModels = [
studentModelBuilder
.joinState(JoinState.NOT_JOINED)
.build()
];

expect(sendInviteButton).toBeTruthy();
});
```

Including only the relevant details in tests makes it easier for future developers to read and understand the purpose of the test.

#### Favor readability over uniqueness
Since tests don't have tests, it should be easy for developers to manually inspect them for correctness, even at the expense of greater code duplication.

Take the following test for example:

```java
@BeforeMethod
public void setUp() {
users = new User[]{new User("alice"), new User("bob")};
}

@Test
public void test_register_canRegisterMultipleUsers() {
registerAllUsers();
for (User user : users) {
assertTrue(forum.hasRegisteredUser(user));
}
}

private void registerAllUsers() {
for (User user : users) {
forum.register(user);
}
}
```

While the code reduces duplication, it is not as straightforward for a developer to follow.

A more readable way to write this test would be:
```java
@Test
public void test_register_canRegisterMultipleUsers() {
User user1 = new User("alice");
User user2 = new User("bob");

forum.register(user1);
forum.register(user2);

assertTrue(forum.hasRegisteredUser(user1));
assertTrue(forum.hasRegisteredUser(user2));
}
```

By choosing readability over uniqueness in writing unit tests, there is code duplication, but the test flow is easier for a reader to follow.


#### Inline mocks in test code

Inlining mock return values in the unit test itself improves readability:

```javascript
it('getStudentCourseJoinStatus: should return true if student has joined the course' , () => {
jest.spyOn(courseService, 'getJoinCourseStatus')
.mockReturnValue(of({ hasJoined: true }));

expect(student.getJoinCourseStatus).toBeTruthy();
});
```

By injecting the values in the test right before they are used, developers are able to more easily trace the code and understand the test.

### Frontend

#### Naming
Unit tests for a function should follow the format:

`"<function-name>: should ... when/if ..."`

Example:

```javascript
it('hasSection: should return false when there are no sections in the course')
```

#### Creating test data
To aid with [including only relevant details in tests](#include-only-relevant-details-in-tests), use the builder in `src/web/test-helpers/generic-builder.ts`

Usage:
```javascript
const instructorModelBuilder = createBuilder<InstructorListInfoTableRowModel>({
email: '[email protected]',
name: 'Instructor',
hasSubmittedSession: false,
isSelected: false,
});

it('isAllInstructorsSelected: should return false if at least one instructor !isSelected', () => {
component.instructorListInfoTableRowModels = [
instructorModelBuilder.isSelected(true).build(),
instructorModelBuilder.isSelected(false).build(),
instructorModelBuilder.isSelected(true).build(),
];

expect(component.isAllInstructorsSelected).toBeFalsy();
});

```

#### Testing event emission
In Angular, child components emit events. To test for event emissions, we've provided a utility function in `src/test-helpers/test-event-emitter`

Usage:
```javascript
@Output()
deleteCommentEvent: EventEmitter<number> = new EventEmitter();

triggerDeleteCommentEvent(index: number): void {
this.deleteCommentEvent.emit(index);
}

it('triggerDeleteCommentEvent: should emit the correct index to deleteCommentEvent', () => {
let emittedIndex: number | undefined;
testEventEmission(component.deleteCommentEvent, (index) => { emittedIndex = index; });

component.triggerDeleteCommentEvent(5);
expect(emittedIndex).toBe(5);
});
```

### Backend

#### Naming
Unit test names should follow the format: `test<functionName>_<scenario>_<outcome>`

Examples:
```java
public void testGetComment_commentDoesNotExist_returnsNull()
public void testCreateComment_commentDoesNotExist_success()
public void testCreateComment_commentAlreadyExists_throwsEntityAlreadyExistsException()
```

#### Creating test data
To aid with [including only relevant details in tests](#include-only-relevant-details-in-tests), use the `getTypicalX` functions in `BaseTestCase`, where X represents an entity.

Example:
```java
Account account = getTypicalAccount();
account.setEmail("[email protected]");

Student student = getTypicalStudent();
student.setName("New Student Name");
```

<include src="development.md#running-tests" />

0 comments on commit db0fd94

Please sign in to comment.