Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Design: Come up with a creative icon related to photos rather than using React icon #14

Open
batunpc opened this issue Nov 16, 2022 · 47 comments · May be fixed by #29
Open

Design: Come up with a creative icon related to photos rather than using React icon #14

batunpc opened this issue Nov 16, 2022 · 47 comments · May be fixed by #29
Assignees
Labels
✨ enhancement New feature or request

Comments

@batunpc
Copy link
Collaborator

batunpc commented Nov 16, 2022

This issue is related to #10 (comment) from the PR raised at #10

While implementing the PWA UI I have used one of the Apple emojis 📸 in the Navbar
CleanShot 2022-11-16 at 14 53 21@2x

Therefore, maybe something related to photos/photography icon could be a good choice.

Alternatively, somebody could design a logo with various tools out there (Adobe products, Canva etc.) easily available.

@mnosov622
Copy link

Hi !

I could come up with the logo. Just let me know the preferences @humphd :)

@humphd
Copy link
Collaborator

humphd commented Nov 18, 2022

I have no preferences! Try something and see what the other devs think.

@mnosov622
Copy link

I've an idea for a logo:

image

What do you think ?

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

@humphd @LostButton @batunpc @saminarp @rudychung @anshul137 @devils2ndself, thoughts?

@CDPhu
Copy link
Collaborator

CDPhu commented Nov 21, 2022

That could work, though personally not a bige fan of that color palette

@rudychung
Copy link
Contributor

Looks good, but agree with @LostButton, could maybe switch up the colors.

@SerpentBytes SerpentBytes added the ✨ enhancement New feature or request label Nov 21, 2022
@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

@mnosov622 First of all, thanks for sharing this with us!

I agree with @LostButton and @rudychung. We could definitely improve the overall design. Maybe choose colours that the rest of us can agree on.

Also, perhaps we could include the project name in the logo?

Let me know your thoughts!

@saminarp
Copy link
Collaborator

saminarp commented Nov 21, 2022

Thank you @mnosov622 for coming up with this! 😃

I also think we can change the colors, experiment with different color palettes and show us different options. Usually, photo-related applications have colorful logos. We can also keep it simple drawing inspiration from other social media logos such as Instagram, Twitter :)

@humphd
Copy link
Collaborator

humphd commented Nov 21, 2022

I really like it! I agree with others that iterating on the colours would be a good idea. Thanks for leading this effort.

@mnosov622
Copy link

mnosov622 commented Nov 21, 2022

Thank you for feedback ! What colors do you think we should consider for a logo ?

@humphd
Copy link
Collaborator

humphd commented Nov 21, 2022

No idea, do some research https://99designs.ca/blog/tips/logo-color-meanings/

@mnosov622
Copy link

image

@mnosov622
Copy link

Or, perhaps, something lighter ?
image

@mnosov622
Copy link

image

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

SerpentBytes commented Nov 22, 2022

@mnosov622 Just an idea: What if we keep the inner lens (the neon bit) and maybe consider it our logo? Could we give each segment a different colour, based on its meaning?

We should rule out colour combinations which would make the logo hard to see when added to the navbar.
In the final version, we could change the text's font family/size/weight/position, etc., and restyle the lens if needed.

You may want to look into https://coolors.co/ as it automatically generates a colour palette.

Let me know your thoughts!

@mnosov622
Copy link

Hi @SerpentBytes .

Got it ! What colors would we prefer ?

@CDPhu
Copy link
Collaborator

CDPhu commented Nov 23, 2022

Hi @SerpentBytes .

Got it ! What colors would we prefer ?

Something that would pop out due to the dark colour of our navbar, maybe a light color pallette

@mnosov622
Copy link

mnosov622 commented Nov 25, 2022

Let me know if I understand the preferences correctly ?
image

Or it's ugly ?

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

SerpentBytes commented Nov 25, 2022

@mnosov622. I am not sure. My previous comment was more of a suggestion than a preference, as logo design is not my strength. Ultimately, you are the designer, so dazzle us, perhaps? 🙂

@mnosov622
Copy link

Sure !

I like this one. Very soft and quite appealing. What do you say ?
image

@mnosov622
Copy link

Hi guys !

What do you think ?

@rudychung
Copy link
Contributor

Not sure if anyone here has played Portal before, but it looks very close to the Aperture Laboratories one. 😆
image
But it should, given that they're both based on the aperture of a camera. Other than that, I think it looks distinct enough to be recognizable.

@humphd
Copy link
Collaborator

humphd commented Nov 28, 2022

Agree, I think the previous one seemed more unique. I wouldn't copy anything existing.

@mnosov622
Copy link

Oh, I didn't know there's similar logo. What do we do then ?

@mnosov622
Copy link

Hi guys !

So, what do we do here ?

@humphd
Copy link
Collaborator

humphd commented Dec 1, 2022

This is a great question, and comes up all the time in open source. Someone has to decide, and often people put it off, or hope someone else will do it.

I'd say we use the original design, not copy an existing one.

I'd like to hear some updates on the research you did about logo colour choices. You never responded to that above.

@mnosov622
Copy link

I didn't copy the existing one. I just took the suggestion above and created a logo with the lenses.

Abou the colors: I think blue color pallete is a good idea for this project to evoke calmness and trust, so that users will use our platform for their needs.

@humphd
Copy link
Collaborator

humphd commented Dec 1, 2022

I didn't copy the existing one. I just took the suggestion above and created a logo with the lenses.

Apologies if it seemed like I said you were copying; that's not what I meant. My point was that we should try to do something unique, now that we know that this other design is already taken.

Abou the colors: I think blue color pallete is a good idea for this project to evoke calmness and trust, so that users will use our platform for their needs.

Sounds good. Can you move toward a PR that includes the logo's raw file(s) as well as generating all the static versions we'll need for various platforms/sizes? You can use something like https://app-manifest.firebaseapp.com/.

@mnosov622
Copy link

I'm sorry. I understood you the wrong way :)

Sure, I will do that !

@mnosov622 mnosov622 linked a pull request Dec 1, 2022 that will close this issue
@mnosov622
Copy link

Hi guys !

What do you think of this logo:
image

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

@mnosov622 That's creative, and I am digging the choice of colours. I think we should use the project name which is "My Photohub"

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

@mnosov622, could you add the logo to the PR you created? Thank you.

@mnosov622
Copy link

Sure !

@mnosov622
Copy link

Or experimenting with font:

image

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

Text using this font could be a little challenging to read for some.

@mnosov622
Copy link

Yeah agree. What about something like that:

image

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

Easier to read. I would wait for feedback from others on this. 👍🏼

@mnosov622
Copy link

Yeah, sure !

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

SerpentBytes commented Dec 4, 2022

I was just wondering, why did you switch from the original font?
Sorry, didn't see one of your comments.

@mnosov622
Copy link

It's okay :)

The bold one looks much more readable !

@mnosov622
Copy link

For now, we've come up with this logo:
image

@saminarp
Copy link
Collaborator

saminarp commented Dec 4, 2022

Yeah agree. What about something like that:

image

I like this one with the bold letters :)

@mnosov622
Copy link

Hi Samina,

Yeah, that looks great !

@mnosov622
Copy link

Yeah agree. What about something like that:
image

I like this one with the bold letters :)

Let me know if we go with this one and I will create icons with different sizes :)

@SerpentBytes
Copy link
Collaborator

LGTM. ✅ I would wait to hear back from others, though.

@batunpc
Copy link
Collaborator Author

batunpc commented Dec 4, 2022

Yeah agree. What about something like that:
image

I like this one with the bold letters :)

Let me know if we go with this one and I will create icons with different sizes :)

I like this one as well 🤩

@rudychung
Copy link
Contributor

Looks good!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
✨ enhancement New feature or request
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

7 participants