diff --git a/RLBotCS/ManagerTools/MatchStarter.cs b/RLBotCS/ManagerTools/MatchStarter.cs
index 53f5fce..0d3821e 100644
--- a/RLBotCS/ManagerTools/MatchStarter.cs
+++ b/RLBotCS/ManagerTools/MatchStarter.cs
@@ -102,7 +102,7 @@ private void PreprocessMatch(MatchSettingsT matchSettings)
             if (playerNames.TryGetValue(playerName, out int value))
             {
                 playerNames[playerName] = ++value;
-                playerConfig.Name = playerName + $" ({value})";
+                playerConfig.Name = playerName + $" ({value + 1})";
             }
             else
             {