diff --git a/csrc/id_model/indexing.cpp b/csrc/id_model/indexing.cpp
index 46edcfe8367..8cc0da959e2 100644
--- a/csrc/id_model/indexing.cpp
+++ b/csrc/id_model/indexing.cpp
@@ -855,14 +855,18 @@ std::vector<Val*> TensorIndexer::getIndexFor(
   const auto& replacement_map = getIndexReplacementMap(
       expr, as_consumer, info.loop_domains, for_loops, info.index_map);
 
-  const auto index_groups = traversalGraph().toGroups(index_ids);
+  // Note that IDs of index_ids may be mapped as the traversal graph
+  // is the AlmostExact graph.
 
   std::vector<Val*> result;
-  result.reserve(index_groups.size());
-  for (const auto& g : index_groups) {
-    auto it = info.index_map.find(g);
+  result.reserve(index_ids.size());
+  for (IterDomain* index_id : index_ids) {
+    const auto& index_group = traversalGraph().toGroup(index_id);
+    auto it = info.index_map.find(index_group);
     NVF_ERROR(
-        it != info.index_map.end(), "Index not found for ", g->toString());
+        it != info.index_map.end(),
+        "Index not found for ",
+        index_id->toString());
     result.push_back(
         ir_utils::replaceValRecursively(it->second, replacement_map));
   }