Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

add relation #19

Open
4 tasks
marqh opened this issue May 4, 2016 · 12 comments
Open
4 tasks

add relation #19

marqh opened this issue May 4, 2016 · 12 comments

Comments

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor

marqh commented May 4, 2016

i want to provide a semantic relationship (skos:broader) between two existing entities

in scope:

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented May 5, 2016

for example, someone may feel that
http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.2/0-3-1
is linked to
http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.2/0-3-0

for pressure reduced to mean sea level (MSL) the broader concept is Pressure

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented May 5, 2016

this can be represeted by the statement:

<http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.2/0-3-1> skos:broader <http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.2/0-3-0>

`Pressure reduced to MSL`      `has a broader concept, which is`     `Pressure` 

https://www.w3.org/2009/08/skos-reference/skos.html#broader

The inference of the relation

`Pressure`                     `has a narrower concept, which is`    `Pressure reduced to MSL`

is automated and should not be encoded.
However, it may be used by other systems, so any definition of narrower needs to be approved carefully. The WMO may decide that this is not to be encoded, to enforce consistency.

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented May 5, 2016

we shall only request that people make the relationship one way

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented May 5, 2016

what does someone need to know in order to propose a link?

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented Jul 28, 2016

page structure is very similar to #36

@Crocstar
Copy link

Pressure reduced to MSL this has a broader concept. The broader concept is Pressure

@Crocstar
Copy link

You can propose a link between two concepts.

For example:

The concept is ‘Pressure reduced to MSL’

You may want to suggest that this has a broader concept and that the broader concept is ‘Pressure’.

We only accept suggestions for concepts to be linked in a broader way.

To make the suggestion:

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented Jul 28, 2016

We only accept suggestions for concepts to be linked in a broader way, the inverse relation is inferred, so we do not encode it.

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented Jul 28, 2016

Before

<http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.2/0-3-1>
        a                skos:Concept , <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/Parameter> ;
        rdfs:label       "Pressure reduced to MSL"@en ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/common/edition>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/codeform/grib2> ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/common/unit>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/common/unit/Pa> ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/category>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.1/0-3> ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/discipline>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/0.0/0> ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/parameter>
                1 ;
        <http://metarelate.net/vocabulary/index.html#identifier>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/category> , <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/discipline> , <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/parameter> , <http://codes.wmo.int/def/common/edition> ;
        dct:description  "Pressure reduced to MSL"@en ;
        skos:prefLabel   "Pressure reduced to MSL"@en .

After

<http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.2/0-3-1>
        a                skos:Concept , <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/Parameter> ;
        rdfs:label       "Pressure reduced to MSL"@en ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/common/edition>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/codeform/grib2> ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/common/unit>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/common/unit/Pa> ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/category>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.1/0-3> ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/discipline>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/0.0/0> ;
        <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/parameter>
                1 ;
        <http://metarelate.net/vocabulary/index.html#identifier>
                <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/category> , <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/discipline> , <http://codes.wmo.int/def/grib2/parameter> , <http://codes.wmo.int/def/common/edition> ;
        dct:description  "Pressure reduced to MSL"@en ;
        skos:prefLabel   "Pressure reduced to MSL"@en ;
        skos:broader <http://codes.wmo.int/grib2/codeflag/4.2/0-3-0> .

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented Jul 28, 2016

highlighter pen:
http://www.devx.com/tips/Tip/13041

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented Oct 14, 2016

#43 has conflicts. updates made to

http://test.wmocodes.info/ui/about/broader

outstanding work:

  • change the title to be h2
  • specific title: How to add a semantic link between concepts.
  • put 'to make the suggestion' onto a new line, to break the flow
  • separate the introduction into paragraphs

close #43

@marqh
Copy link
Contributor Author

marqh commented Oct 14, 2016

separate the introduction into paragraphs

You can propose a link between two concepts. We only accept suggestions for concepts to be linked in a broader way, the inverse 'narrower' relation is inferred so we do not encode it. 

For example: The concept is ‘Pressure reduced to MSL’ You may want to suggest that this has a broader concept and that the broader concept is ‘Pressure’. 

To make the suggestion:

mike-gormley pushed a commit that referenced this issue Jun 16, 2022
Updated `_hlist-render-child.vm` to address issue #18.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants