You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The simplesom and somoclu summarizers have "summarizer" in the name of their inform stages, but in theory SOM models ought to be usable for SOM-based estimators, too, and it's something we should probably add in the foreseeable future due to the popularity of SOMs for estimation as well as summarization. This issue is for defining an Inform\* stage that can work for a SOM performing estimation or summarization, along with writing a CatEstimator stage for at least one and preferably both SOM approaches, and modifying the various examples/pipelines to refer to the generic Inform\* stage. I've tagged @yanzastro and @sschmidt23 because you have the most experience with SOMs in RAIL, but this issue is in fact open to anyone.
We should also take this opportunity to address an inconsistency in the naming of the parent class for these two summarizers; they take a spec-z catalog and test set photometry, but the SZPZSummarizer class literally says they're taking a p(z) catalog and spec-z catalog. It doesn't look like this class actually comes up anywhere else so it should be straightforward to rename it CatSZSummarizer/SZCatSummarizer along the way. (I'm also unclear on why the spec-zs are needed by the summarizer after the model is created -- is it just to get the weights between the photometric catalog and the spectroscopic training set, in which case could that be carried as part of the saved model so these would just be CatSummarizers? Sorry if I'm totally misunderstanding how these work!)
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I edited the title to include classification because it would generalize the applicability of #1. If the classifier produces labels corresponding to SOM cells, then a stage for the quality control would perform different selections based on quantities derived from the galaxies divided into their SOM cells, and then the reduced overall sample could become input to any Summarizer.
The simplesom and somoclu summarizers have "summarizer" in the name of their inform stages, but in theory SOM models ought to be usable for SOM-based estimators, too, and it's something we should probably add in the foreseeable future due to the popularity of SOMs for estimation as well as summarization. This issue is for defining an
Inform\*
stage that can work for a SOM performing estimation or summarization, along with writing aCatEstimator
stage for at least one and preferably both SOM approaches, and modifying the various examples/pipelines to refer to the genericInform\*
stage. I've tagged @yanzastro and @sschmidt23 because you have the most experience with SOMs in RAIL, but this issue is in fact open to anyone.We should also take this opportunity to address an inconsistency in the naming of the parent class for these two summarizers; they take a spec-z catalog and test set photometry, but the
SZPZSummarizer
class literally says they're taking a p(z) catalog and spec-z catalog. It doesn't look like this class actually comes up anywhere else so it should be straightforward to rename itCatSZSummarizer
/SZCatSummarizer
along the way. (I'm also unclear on why the spec-zs are needed by the summarizer after the model is created -- is it just to get the weights between the photometric catalog and the spectroscopic training set, in which case could that be carried as part of the saved model so these would just beCatSummarizer
s? Sorry if I'm totally misunderstanding how these work!)The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: